Edelweiss Review
When
Mangagamer first entered the eroge market on July 10, 2008, their entrance was
met with surprise and quickly disdain. The reason for this was because their
initial lineup was made up largely by pretty second rate looking sex romp games,
the only exception being Edelweiss because unlike the others it had a good
story, a well established cast of characters, good artwork, and excellent
music. There was one fatal flaw though that kept this game from saving the
newly emerged MG from being redeemed in the naysayers eyes, the translation
quality. At this point MG’s translation staff consisted of translators to whom
English was a second (though I highly suspect third, fourth, or lower) language
and as far as could be seen, no editors to proofread. This meant that while the
games didn’t have any hilariously bad engrish moments (ie, Metal Gear’s “I feel
asleep”), they would be chock full of typoes, bad grammar, and run on sentences
to name a few and sadly Edelweiss got the worst of it due to it being longer
than the other games released with it. Since I’d heard that the story was good,
I bought Edelweiss and played through it; I found the game to have a very
enjoyable story but having to read through a script with so many typoes you’d
think it was typed via feet I ended up joining the naysayers in believing that
MG wouldn’t last a year. Fortunately MG listened to all the criticism and
cleaned up their act, and on September 2, 2011 they released a properly
translated Edelweiss, with buyers of the previous version able to access this
new version for free.
Pros: Good story, well written characters, good artwork,
animated character models, good music.
Cons: The first 2-3 hours of the game.
WTF!?: When visiting Eiden Island, lookout for the deranged walking,
talking, killer sign post.
In
Edelweiss you play as Kazushi Haruma one of four new transfer students to an
island school called Eiden Academy. The island is well known for teaching its
students alchemy, but that’s not why Kazushi and his three idiot pals have
transferred. They know that the school has only just recently changed from
being an all girls’ school, and as a result this school filled entirely with
girls must be the perfect place for them to score. Oh the surprises that await
them...
Okay, for
once I’m going to be pointing out my main gripe about this game at the start.
The reason is simple, after the introduction part of the beginning the first
two to three hours of this game suck. It’s pretty much a series of gag
scenarios straight out of your typical harem comedy anime which are so generic
and predictable they’re not funny and the fact that many of these scenes occur
as a result of the antics of Kazushi’s idiot friends will have you wondering
how any sane man could tolerate their presence without either running away or
attempting murder. I freely admit that I was lamenting the purchase I had made
at this point until a story arc occurred involving one of those three idiot
characters. The start of this arc caught my interest since its start was both
ironically funny and I couldn’t help but feel sadistic glee at seeing a character
that had annoyed me since almost the start of the game be put in a situation
that had him downright miserable. However, what was in store for me was a truly
pleasant surprise as this arc evolved into a truly interesting story that added
some complexity to two characters that I had considered to be the most one
dimensional up until that point. I won’t spoil anything as I consider this arc
to be one of the best moments of the game, but I will say that at the end of it
I was surprised at how hooked I’d been to the story and how much I’d cared
about what happened with those two aforementioned characters when not too long
ago I’d been complaining about both, and trust me it was all uphill from there.
After that
odd slump at the beginning, the story begins to shine in not only providing
good character expositions, but the many scenes that follow are both
interesting and funny. You become attached to the characters very quick as you
learn more about them, some traits that you may have at first found annoying
about some of the characters actually become quirks, and you really get a good
feel for the story setting as Kazushi and co. get used to life on this odd (to
say the least) island. All of these story elements do well in providing the
right setup for when the story diverges into each heroine’s route, each one
containing a unique and overall well written story that reveals considerable
depth to the chosen heroine’s personality, backstory, and in some cases adds
depth to some other characters that have some connection the scenario.
Anyway, in
case anyone is interested, here’s where the scenario’s rank in my book, from
favorite to not so favorite:
1)
Tie between Haruka and Mizuki
2)
Natsume
3)
Mei
4)
Ran
Another story element I should
address before moving on is the setting. Like Da Capo, the island that the game
takes place on does have an air of mystery about it that makes it that even the
weirdest things that occur seem plausible. The difference is that Edelweiss
doesn’t give its mystery as much depth as Da Capo and instead uses it more as a
way for the story to revel in how strange the island can get.
Moving on to the presentation, I
have to say that this is where Edelweiss succeeds. The artwork is very good, be
it for the characters, the CG or the background, the characters area all well
voiced with the exception of Kazushi who isn’t voiced, and the music is well
picked for setting the mood of the story. A good bonus is that the character
profiles that are shown in the typical dialogue scenes are animated, meaning
you’ll see their lips moving as they talk.
As for the ero scenes, they’re
okay. That’s about all I can really say about them. They’re well drawn and
placed at the right points for them to occur in their respective heroine’s
scenarios, but they don’t really add to or take away that much from the story.
In Conclusion:
Edelweiss is an overall very good
game with a good story and great cast of characters to match. The comedy and
drama in both the common story and each scenario is mostly well written and
enjoyable to read. Yes, I’ll admit that the beginning isn’t very good, but the
story payoff for enduring what’s really a very short portion of the game is
very much worth it. Considering the price has dropped quite a bit since its
first release and the retranslated version is a great improvement, I would
definitely recommend this for purchase. You can also buy a physical copy that
includes the main game and fandisk here.
Final Score: 7/10 Great
Author Recommendation: Buy it now
No comments:
Post a Comment